Art Caplan, a bioethicist and the director of the Division of Medical Ethics at New York University’s Grossman School of Medicine, told CNN that as Trump’s doctor, Conley had a duty to his patient, meaning he wouldn’t share information without the President’s permission. “That leaves the public in many ways in the dark about serious problems that might come up,” he said.
But Conley also had a duty to warn as a physician, Caplan argued, if his patient could have put others at risk.
“Ethically, any doctor has an obligation to make sure their patient does not harm others,” he said. “So, if you knew Trump was positive and you knew he was going to an event unmasked and you knew there were vulnerable people going to be there … I would argue you have an obligation to speak up and notify them.”
Caplan added: “It’s probably the last thing you ever do as the White House doctor if you do it, but nonetheless, you have a duty to protect people from harm, and exposing people to Covid is absolutely dangerous, and I think requires you to break the presumption of privacy.”
Jackson was Conley’s predecessor at the White House Medical Office, where he convened an extraordinary news conference describing Trump in “excellent health” after his 2018 physical exam, despite evidence of heart disease and borderline obesity. Later, after Trump nominated Jackson to become Veterans Affairs secretary, allegations of misconduct emerged, including drinking on the job. A subsequent Defense Department inspector general report earlier this year offered a scathing review of Jackson’s conduct as White House doctor.
As White House doctors, both Conley and Jackson were serving the Navy. But they answered to the White House — not the Pentagon — in their roles as White House military officials.
When Jackson was investigated by the Defense Department inspector general over his conduct as White House doctor, it was the result of the inspector general receiving specific complaints about him. So far, there is no indication of any complaints being made against Conley.
A Navy official referred CNN to the White House when asked for comment on Conley. Conley has not responded to CNN’s request for comment.
The close proximity can generate a relationship that goes beyond the typical patient-doctor dynamic. Biden, who replaced Conley with Dr. Kevin O’Connor as his doctor after taking office, asked O’Connor to join him when he met Pope Francis at the Vatican in October.
It’s not uncommon for a president to name his own physician when taking office, though Biden’s two most recent predecessors each retained the incumbent doctor who had attended the men who served before them.
‘Breached his duty’
The shielding of a president’s health problems is nothing new. But the questions surrounding the conduct of Trump’s White House doctors underscore how the last administration’s willingness to mislead — and lie outright — often permeated all corners of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.
Dr. Jonathan Reiner, a professor of medicine and surgery at George Washington University, told CNN’s Jake Tapper Wednesday that Conley “breached his duty” for not isolating Trump.
“If I were the White House physician and I was told, ‘Don’t say anything about this,’ I would resign,” Reiner said.
According to the Guardian, Conley called Meadows the night of September 26 when Trump was en route to a rally in Pennsylvania, telling him Trump had tested positive. Meadows wrote that Conley told him, “Stop the President from leaving. He just tested positive for Covid,” according to the excerpt.
Trump was subsequently tested again and received a negative result. Meadows wrote that Trump took the negative test as “full permission to press on as if nothing had happened.”
“I didn’t want to take any unnecessary risks,” Meadows wrote, according to The Guardian, “but I…